On this page
- Departments (1)
-
Text (4)
-
Untitled Article
-
Untitled Article
-
Untitled Article
-
LITERARY BIOGRAPHY.*
Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.
-
-
Transcript
-
Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.
Additionally, when viewing full transcripts, extracted text may not be in the same order as the original document.
Untitled Article
put forth at the shprtesfc notice a deluge of the veriest truisms , and torment the reader with merciless self-repetitions . ¦ ; . . We do n 6 t demand bran-new moral truths ; they are not so easily found ; perhaps any man who could produce fiye ^ such really * would be the greatest man of the day : we can aim at little mpre than . to give fresh and unexpected illustrations , cite very ^ remarkable examples , throw the light very strongly ojvone faeelet-of a diamond truth ; show an unknown root , or a fresh ramification , make up complements that have been omitted by others , abbreviate the results of a wide induction into as few words .-as possible , and as wide ead
strong , or call some authoritative witness against a . -spr fallacy . In default of an absolute and almost impossible originality , the above requirements are what a reader may fairly make of a man who comes forward as the propounded and propagator of moral truths ; and , as far as these requirements are concerned , we consider the present volume , in the main , a failure . "Up to a ; certain point of excellence , a writer who seeks eminence in this department , it department it can be called , should come , and the line must be held tightly . The author has great reading ; but this reading-appears to us not to have produced its simplest good effect , —that of avoiding
ten more repetitions of what he must have met with ten , or nlty times , it may be , in tie several authors---and their name is legionwith whose works he seems to be familiar . The best effect of his varied reading is , that it has made him liberal , possibly even too liberal to men holding the most opposite opinions ; it has given him a very wide range of sympathy and of charity for all , even for those who have had very little charity themselves . . The quotations are numerous , and form an important part of the work ; they are from the Greek and Latin , and all the higher modern European languages : some are very good ; with reference to liiany of them , the following remarks of Sir Thomas Brown , in his ^ Vulgar Errors , ' * are applicable . "We urge authorities on points that need not , and introduce the testimony of ancient authors to confirm things evidently believed ; and whereto iio reasonable hearer but would attest to them .. . . which , although known and trivial
vulgar , are frequently urged by many men ; and , though verities in our mouths , yet noted from Plato , Ovid ; and Cicero , they become reputed elegances . " We have not attempted to test all the quotations and references , bnt some are irrelevant . With their :.: ' context We happen to be familiar . That from Dante ' s * ' Purgatorio / ' for instance , page 69 , has no reference whatever to the matter which the , author is urging , nor is it even applicable , or in point , as a loose line . Again , the four lines from " Monti , " page 1 ^ 5 , previously used by Madame de Stciel in the " Cormrie ' are certainly very little to the point , and had the author knowii the poem which he cites , he might have found trivial
four others there really to his purpose . To prove a proposition , viz ., " There is indeed a soul in nature , and that sOulis God , " he adduces three lines of a Sophoclean fragment , which merely state , with pure Greek simplicity , that there is one God who made heaven , earth , and sea . Such quotations are pedantry , if they are not worse , the result of calculation upon the ignorance of the reader . The truisms are very fatiguing . We detest garbled quotations from an author whom we are reviewing , and we will show this , as briefly , and at the same time as fairly , as we cap . The author ; Jf wordy , is seldom absolutely pompous , ; though he is so once or twice , when he has to make what appears to him to be an important enunciation . We will take then two of theses
( Page 177 . ) «* Were it possible then , it should be blazoned in characters of light , proclaimed as with ft thunder ' s roll , that our powers must be exercised and developed to be retained . " .. < ....., ( Vnge 228 . ) " Peal it then through furthest heaven , no one is good in vaiii . " W © have taken two- cases of magnificent announcement purposely , and leave it for the reader to judge whether the wool is worth , the cry . Such verities do not need repeating , even as premises or intermediate propositions , much less as conclusions . We should be very sorry to maintain what we have said at the expense of the reader ' s temper and patience by further quotations of the same description , which we might make by the hundred . If JDr . M'Cormack's " still voice" were not sometimes better than his thunder peals , we should never have , taken the trouble to review him so much at length . There is much and high meaning in the following : —
" Manners , in troth , make ua free of the angelic kingdom , and . founded on goodness and love iinply the very courtesies of heaven . JTor if > ve shall but reflect , the essential happiness of this life and of the Jife to oorao muatneods include the commerce—itself celestial—of natures proyreeBively elevated with each other , and with God . " ( pp . 48 , 49 . ) " The atheism of which I would apeak is of a yet more disastrous stump —acknowledging God , but loving Hum not ; professing charity ) but evincing none ; admitting God's existence with as little feeling as it is denied by some : the atheism of the heart , in short , if not the atheism of tho understanding . " ( p . 43 . ) ¦ . . . ....
" For all aolf-imposed limitation—and every new duty is a limitationwhich is a condition of n real exercise of the spiritual or higher lifo , is the reverse of a real limitation , reconciles us in so far with God . " ( p . 68 . ) "It id only what tho soul drinks in with eagerness that becomes thoroughly and perfectly its own . " ( p . 00 . ) Wo could heartily wish that such matter predominated in the book , and that there were loss verbiage . Extensive reading ought to givo an author mastery over language , not language mastery over him . The stylo is Bomowhat Germanic nnd Emersonian , but without tha strength and orig-innlity of Emerson- —when he chooses to write practically nnd not mystically . The original German clement in the English mind and atylo is moat vnluablo , the imported rnther sickening- nndjitdd . •? Silence is golden , " quotes Ciirlylo ; we believe so , from
Untitled Article
LEIGH HUNT may be taken as the representative literary journalist of the first half of the nineteenth century . J ± e would not be able to take that position at any later date . Ihmgs have altered , and , as we hope , for the better , since .. The pecuniary status , certainly , has undergone a great change and improvement . Literature has become more of a profession . Tins fact alone ^ wouJd disqualify the editor of the " Examiner" and " Indicator for the situation , for he would no longer have the excuse for Ins personal Huntin his
embarrassments that in his time really existed . Leigh , autobiography , attributes these to his own ineptitude for accounts ; this may have blinded him to the fact as it stood ; but that tact was , though he could not see it , that the world was then opposed to the journal-craftsman , and , he had to win his ^ bread against desperate Odds . Now , a maVket has been opened for him , and tlie juvenile adventurer of talent can find in it a ready resource * while Waiting for liis opportunity in the greater world , or may safely make in it an abiding ^ plaee with ] the fair chance of a permanent income . the
Weare not of those , then , who regard pecuniary position or Leigh Hunt as a fault in the man , rather than as a misfortune trom which it was scarcely possible for an individual in his position to escape . He was one of an army of martyrs , whose sufferings were needed as the condition of the world ' improvement , and the establishment of a new order or profession—arid lie was remarkably well fitted for the post by his antecedents and his disposition . Ihe son of a liberal clergyman , with West Indian blood in his-veins , thrown upon the world to live by his wits , there was just the instinct and the necessity in his nature and circumstances to tall into the way of life which he had adopted , and to follow its chances and fortunes with as much and success as were likely toattend
courage ^ the efforts of any similar aspirant . In some respects , he had _ many advantages . There was in him the creative mind of the poet , with much of the execntive power ; and an adroitness in pvpse composition which stood him in good stead in the production of literary and critical essays , that were designed rather to appeal to popular feelings , than to display either erudition or orthodoxy . As to the latter , the age was in a state of transition , and as that state is always a painful one , there is no reason to wonder that Leigh iiunt , witli his Unitarianism and Universnlistii , which he derived from lus _ father , though the latter was a clergyman of the Church of Eno-land . e-ot sometimes into trouble with the religious world .
Nobody will now care what his theological opinions were ; but what he did for literature and civil liberty will live in the remembrance of mankind , in whatever manner the popular creed may be modified , whether the form of belief become more or loss laUtudmarian than it was , or is , either in his times or our . own , In one point Leigh Hunt had a groat ndvantnge . He was a wit ; an elegant wit , who had studied in the school of our dramatists , novelists , and essayists , and had caught their spirit and their mantle . He belonged , also , to a guild , a brotherhood ot wits-j-Hoolr
Charles Lamb , Thomas Campbell , the two Smiths , 'lheodore , Thomas Moore , Coleridge ,,, Keats , Byron , Shelley . Of all these , Shelley comes onfc more magnificently than any other . Ho gave Leigh Hunt no less than fourteen hundred pounds to pay his dojjta with ; and , to complete tho jest , tho debtor waa not at Just relieved , but suffered the full penalty for a email outstanding liability . Aho world may laugh ; , but Shelby ' s magnanimity was none the Jess , whether its gwi belong either to the broad or narrow gunge . U » the railway , of life such a benefactor la seldom met with . After nil , Leigh Hunt was more a man of taste than of genius . Hia faults belong to the former character ; liia morita also . Ho
* Tho Autobiography of Loi < , h Hunt . A Now JMHion , revised by the Author ; with further lfevislbn ,. and an Introduction by his Eldest Sow . 9 mitJ » Elder , and Oo , , i / /•// , Mwcmlayi tho HMarlan , Stafamaw , and JfoMMM * f ™* f $ nfJwi Life and £ Uar « n / Labour ^ , tplth . aomo Aoouuni < f lib JSci > 'lj / . «>«( Unknown . Writint / 8 . John Cunnden Wotton .
Untitled Article
what it costs some people to keep it , and the precious privilege thereby secured to their non-hearers ; " and speech ^ silvern r but of all iinds defend us from German silver ; of the , we r athe prefer the worstBritish metal , for thereis less pretentiousness aboul it . At the same time , we can honour suc ^ writers a * Jean ^ Vzui , and we wish Dr . M'Cormack had not alluded to Richter s . far , fetched analogies , for it reminds us forcibly of a power \ vh 1 ch 7 he himself wants , apd which would have supplied him with a few more new metaphors and simileS . , In many of tho author ' s doctrines we do not concur , but we liave not allowed this disagreement to taint our ciiticism ; we should be proud to share that kindliness of spirit > yhich some readers m ^ y prefer tb terseness and novelty , but which , without them , generally makes a man rather loved than read . ; ' ¦ _ ¦ ¦ T . . He is an universalist ; intimates that a man may degrade lmnseli infinitely / but does not appear to describe the process or dehne the luixuxvcij , " ¦*?•' .. i'C , , „ .,. L oomnnv rtf the volume he ?
perioa or sen-recovery , xuwmuo ^^ ? , — r" , ji 1 4 . 0 .-1 iQWC Senies " retribution , " but elsewhere says that » God s violated laws do most assuredly vindicate themselves , " which we fancy , comes to much the samellnng ; but We apologise if we have misunderstood his meaning . The author admires and counsels benevolence , ^ think that he willfind more extensive and practical exhlb ^ , lon 9 J ?* ' * in men of what he apparently considers the narrow creed of the ijnglish Church , as ordinarily received , than amongst German dreameis and speculators , as there are exponents of its ^ doctrines amongst om great divines and moralists , the study of whose works would decidedly improve his style .
Untitled Article
F ^ b ' / IB ; 1860 J The header cmd Saturday Analyst * 16 ^
Literary Biography.*
LITERARY BIOGRAPHY *
-
-
Citation
-
Leader (1850-1860), Feb. 18, 1860, page 163, in the Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition (2008; 2018) ncse-os.kdl.kcl.ac.uk/periodicals/l/issues/vm2-ncseproduct2334/page/15/
-