On this page
- Departments (1)
-
Text (4)
-
fuxthiw.
-
Untitled Article
-
Untitled Article
-
Untitled Article
Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.
-
-
Transcript
-
Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.
Additionally, when viewing full transcripts, extracted text may not be in the same order as the original document.
Untitled Article
of the dronh ! Lot * . see what the Her . John Jactson-the * ew ^ Taf ^ r ^ che ' : rs ^ ffilriariitT ^ rXve at present condBfted us ^ e ^ rS the pal m to the Bishop , . as . being tto better on his side of the question whom we b . ave yet met with . He lias done , we tot as xnucircan be effected by any advocate ^ what we sincerely believe to be an essentially worthless cause ; and he Y ^^ TT ^ m fair and temperate spirit ; except in certain places , where he allows himself ( see pages 9 andlO ) to impute mean and mercenary motives to those who oppose his own views-an act of injustice which we should hardly have expected from a writer who sets out by reprobating personalities of any kind in the first page of his pamphlet discusses the the grounds of its own
-The Bishop wisely subject" on pro moters " -so far , at least , as he can see overthem He begins his > tract by some of those learned references to " the law of Moses , to " Constantme and to " Theodosius , " which we consider to have no direct bearing on the question now under consideration ; and which he himself admits ( page 5 ) to be beside the point on which he is writing . This " point is thus S The infrafdiate effect then of this measure "—the opening of the Crystal Palace on Sunday— " would be to oblige a large number of men , employed m such places of amusement , to work on Sunday as well as on other days , probably without any proportionate increase of wages , in many cases against their consciences , and in all cases to their great injury , both physically and morally . Now , what right have we to inflict this injury only for our own amusement ?" The above passage reads very glibly and clearly ; but the same logical clever
fallacy which lies at the bottom of the Bishop's otherwise argument throughout its whole course , is visible enough , to those who choose to see it , here . This fallacy may be thus briefly stated : —The writer introduces certain assumptions of his own , which may or may not be true , tor the purpose of arguing from them immediately afterwards , as if they were proved matters of fact . There are three assumptions , for instance , m the passage we have quoted . The Bishop assumes—1 st , That persons employed in the Crystal Palace on Sundays would work on that day without proportionate increase of wages ; 2 nd , That they would be obliged to work against their consciences ; 3 rd , That they would be injured physically and morally by such labour . Having stated these assumptions , he instantly argues ( aS if they were all granted and all true ) that we shall be inflicting an injury for our own amusement , m opening the Crystal Palace on Sunday . Let us now assume on our "de—lst . That the Directors of the Crystal Palace Company are sufficiently liberal and honourable gentlemen to pay tlie labourer liberally and honourably ( more especially when the eyes of England are on them ) for whatever work he does on the seventh day ; 2 nd , That church accommodation in the ^ ig ^ bourh ° o fl ° Sydenham will be provided for the persons employed in the Park and the Palace , and such a system of military relief on duty be adopted , as shall ^^ Bftable all servan ts of the Company to attend service on Sunday at one hWoTtEe day or another ; 3 rd , That thia relief on duty , and this wmmmmm ^ eriment hasten tried , than the assumptions of our opponentj-and = y ^ Mis » 5 » &Eis
It ^ r-d ^ Sy" Xta ^^ 7 ' d ^ & ^ wed to rat ^^ the Sabbath , a / d not traders in cotton too P We answer at once SJ t ^^ St now opL in London on a Sunday when , a ^ ^ I' ^ lolZd plus earnings impurely . Where is there any p « o a wl " could HDcncl 1 heimuoiv innocently than at the door ol the Crystal ± alacc r Hl l"'rl . a ,, fl . refer , in this plaec , before concluding the present notice Toihc W <> 1 »' h Jc ^ " ' » l » P ™«* against the performance of any ™; ' « 1 < I } 1 V . Jif he were ro ally unaware that there , b p lenty of work that j
already Koing on , in our house * and out of our houses , on day . » u , as ho * S tiiin peculiar Sabbatarian delusion , in common vrith many other writers of many other tracts , which we have yet to review , we pro-S waTJnp toHpmk fully on Ibis part of the Hubjcct , Irom some now text , at our earliest available opportunity .
Fuxthiw.
fuxthiw .
Untitled Article
IT . . ^ . d do our nlmo . L , 'M ^^ ZS ? " ™ - * " ' ° ^ ° '" "
Untitled Article
332 ' ¦ ¦ ' *¦ - " —~—~ r ~
THE LEADER , ^ SATUB ^ i _
Untitled Article
A 3 T 0 RT © F A DRESS . PI MONG the sights of London I encountered one that 1 little expected ill to hcc , and it may not be uninteresting to some ol cur friends down ft South ! I wan looking at the palace of the Kings-not at a I equal ai \ to the White House which is opea to every c . tr / . ea-aml it was there thai , a sight struck me which was not quite pleasant lor one of Uncle Sam ' s nephews . A bevy of fair ladum were leaving a great house , * ««« % .- a Dan of Hoot , or a Dm , of WorhT By John Jackson . London : Hkcliinj » ton .
with a crowd of folk s looking at them , and police to keep order . The ladies had been attending a meeting to sympathise with Uncle Tom—that benighted and maundering Old Nigger whose jargon helps to prevent our real statesmen from making the men of the South even listen to reason . The poor ladies , however , looked more fit for a hall , or a morning concert , than for any political work in earnest ; and their countenances were guilty of nothing worse than a little holiday bustle , newly spiced with Black
pepper . T , But something was to happen besides this " Uncle-Tomene . In the crowd I saw a young couple , who were waiting out of more than mere curiosity . You could see that by the eye of the girl . The young man also watched the ladies as they came out , but evidently his care was the girl . At last a lady issued from the door—a tall , handsome woman , with fine aristocratic features , bold yet delicate ; a very voluptuous countenance , if the sensuous look had not been rendered harsh by a slight habitual sneer
of scorn , verv common with English people of " high' birth ; " her face being also , if it is not rude to say so , a little hardened by time . She must have been a glorious creature , and she looked to think herself still so . She was in no hurry—haste would have spoiled her costume . I wish I could describe it , but that would need a less republican pen than mine . Her noble throat rose out of a wide expanse of delicate and brilliant silk , softened with a large white shawl and a variety of lace , or whatever else it was ; but the taste of the arrangement disposed the mass of soft strips so as to display , and not to disguise , the grace of her tall and rather slender figure . . , "That gown , " said I to the young man , " cost more m the making than
in the stuff . ' ' 1 " It might in your country , " he answered , turning round sharp to look at me—though I did not know that I had any peculiar accent ; " but in this country the labour is the least part of the cost ; except to the labourer . " He had an accent not quite English . " What have all these fair ladies been doing , sir ? " I asked . « Meeting about Uncle Tom , " said he . " I wish they would look to the slaves in their own country . " _ ~ " We don ' t get up abolition meetings for the White Niggers of
Manchester , sir , " said I . "No , " said he , "I wish you did . But Manchester is . not our fcoutn . There , are worse places than that not so far off . " The fine lady came down the steps , and then the young woman , who had not attended at all to us , stepped close to the lady and spoke to her .
A policeman came forward to remove the girl ; and my blood boiled to see a fellow in a glazed hat attempt to touch a female ; but the lady herseli S ? that , but unbelieving . The girl again spoke ; ^*» ^ «*« ° »^ and then the lady motioned to the girl to get mto her carnage . They both got in ; and after a few words to the footman—a fine gentleman m a lovely , Ielicate , blue coat , with white gloves , and cheeks like a girl ' s-the carnage ^ Thc ^ oung man looked for an instant into my face and then asked me if I coid run . Without reply , I joined him in following the carnage . We an barelv a mile , and then we arrived at the door of a poor house in a . mail street , before the carriage . The young man followed the woman , and I followed himnobodstopping me , I suppose because I did not look
, y a Vl ex c ed they would . A ' sense of silence came over us as we went up Stairs ! P and the rustling of the fine lady ' s dress was ^^ mZZ we crept up . We all entered a small room , and as we did so a child began Zcry The young woman took it from another who held it , to suckle it and so to stay the little voice which disturbed the quiet room with its hG !^ thicke st at the further end , on a narrow , white bed , whLh the Ly approached , and gazed upon . On it lay . y- ^ but partially undressed , ghastly pale , w . th her eyes -closed By he , « de with its bead pillowed on the ana that partly clasped it , lay 1 Ukdi d like its mother in paleness , like her in its dosed eyes ; but unlike her , who e breath was scarcely heard , ia its short and ^ " \ ^ " £ ^ would have been louil , bud it not sunk to the burned whisper of deporting
We all Ra » xl for a minute ia silence , and in reverence for mortal sufferin . , which callB ,-alike republican and aristocrat , rich and poor to account Tit ; lady looked at the sick woman , and then at the dark-eyed young g , r who had broug ht her , and who kept her eye . fixed on the lady : the proud woman ' s look seemed to ask why she had been brought there . « lossy wished me to fetch you , " cried the happier mother , for she could nourish aud quiet her child . I noticed that there was no ring upon h Aw ' tlTil K ^ But I would hav e assisted her , without" imd the ladv put her hand into her pocket for her purse . " ho it is too late for that . You must ilo something else for her , and
You are bound—you are doubly bound . * ,. „ , Atraia the lady ' s proud eyes looked a question . There was no fear m her iW but her glaaec round implied a challenge of the right to keep her 1 was your haughty haste that killed her ; it was yours that brought her so near death . Yes , Lady Julia , I do not mean to offend you , but you
-
-
Citation
-
Leader (1850-1860), April 2, 1853, page 332, in the Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition (2008; 2018) ncse-os.kdl.kcl.ac.uk/periodicals/l/issues/vm2-ncseproduct1980/page/20/
-