On this page
-
Text (2)
-
Untitled Article
-
Untitled Article
Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.
-
-
Transcript
-
Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.
Additionally, when viewing full transcripts, extracted text may not be in the same order as the original document.
Untitled Article
Nature never teaches distrust of tender love-tales , What < Mn hare 'aught her distru > t of all my vows ? No , she does not doubt me ! on a dewy eve-tide Whispering together beneath the listening moon , I piay'd till her cheek flush'd , implored till she faltered—< Fluttered to my bosom— ah ! to fly away so soon " When her mother tends her before the laughing mirror , Tying up her laces , looping up her hair , Often she thinks—were this wild thing wedded , I should have more love , and much less care . . When hpr mother tends her before the bashful mirror ,
Loosening her laces , combing down her curls , Often she thinks—were this wild thing wedded , I should lose but one for so many boys and girls . " Deckar , in one of his chaotic plays , uses the quaint but truthful simile , " untameabie as flies ; the same observation of Nature is implied in Mr . Meredith ' s" Then Winter , he who tamed the fly !" But the verse is rather quaint than poetic , inasmuch as it is throwing Winter into insignificance to select fly-taming as the characteristic of its power . We noticed other examples of this same tendency ; but the whole volume is too obviously a collection of trifles to demand close criticism . We notice it because the workmanship of these trifles is elegant and fanciful .
Untitled Article
MESMERIC TEACHERS . Somnolism and Psycheism ; or the Science of the Soul and the Phenomena of Nervation , as revealed by Vital Magnetism , or Mesmerism , considered Physiologically and Philosophically . By Joseph W . Haddock , M . D . Second Edition . J . S . Hodson . Our readers know that the Facts of Mesmerism meet with little scepticism from us , and that the theories with which men seek to establish a science —prematurely , indeed , but nevertheless , honestlyare respectfully listened to . There are many facts in Mesmerism , and those cardinal , which we find it impossible to doubt ; but there are many facts reported which we find it as impossible to believe upon any evidence yet offered ; indeed , we must say , that a writer who can consent to publish such narratives as some of the Mesmeric teachers insolently throw down before the world , with a believethis - or - be - accounted - a - bigot - and - opponent- oftruth air , ought not to be surprised if they are laughed at . and held as impostors . These men are the real obstructors to the progress of their science . It is they who bring discredit upon it . The grand phrases about the martyrs of science have almost ceased to have significance . Men are avid of novelty j but they hate pretension now as of old . They are willing enough to accept facts upon acceptable evidence ; but are properly sceptical of astounding novelties when the intellectual condition of the reporter is such as to throw suspicion on hi . s statements .
It is easy to talk of Galileo and Harvey . Every man who invents a brass candlestick , or improved shaving-strop , which people refuse to employ , rails at the " bigotry of the age , " exclaiming , E pur si muove J Every unread poet is neglected , " like Milton "; every bad musician recalls the fate of Beethoven . But all this railing is ineffective ; the world goes its own way , sweeps majestic through its orbit , quite undisturbed by these apostrophes . Give us facts and experiments in Mesmerism , not such as may be vouched by " highly respectable , "
perfectly credulous , and stupid witnesses , hut such as cany with them a weight of evidence proportionate to the demand made upon belief—throw your doors open wide to impartial investigation—« eek to get at the real truth , and do not patch up cases—allow sceptics to place their own conditions— 'and then we will vouch for there being no inordinate scepticism on the part of the public . 15 ut , if instead of doing thin . Mesmerists confine themselves to private performances , money-making exhibitions , and writing foolish hooks , then public
scepticism ih a virtue . Dr . Gregory ' s Letters to a Candid Inquirer , recently reviewed by us , is a bqok to advance the Hubjccf ;; throughout you fuel an unfeigned respect for the author , and Una given weight to his opinions , even when your own conviction most widely separates from them . It ' in quite clear that Dr . Gregory wishes to get at the truth ; them i . n no trace of the charlatan in Inn book ; and even when he reports astounding facts , you do not turn aside in disgust , but wish that you could yourself haw been present to have seen what it really wan that has ho shaped itnelf in hia miiuL Dr , Haddock ' s book ia by no means of this class . He ia altogether an unprepossessing writer .
I It may be literary prejudice , but we cannot help suspecting the statements of a man who writes such a style as Dr . Haddock writes ; not simply because it is a flaccid style , without life as without colour , but because such loose writing implies inaccurate thinking . A man of science is not bound to write with the felicity of phrase which we demand in literature ; but if he writes in a commonplace and slipshod style , it is because be thinks in that style . We may explain ourselves , perhaps , by saying that Dr . Gregory ' s book made us feel cautious about our scepticism ; Dr . Haddock ' s made us cautious about our belief . Dr . Gregory will make converts ; Dr . Haddock will make just opponents . All that relates to the history and philosophy of Mesmerism in this volume is feeble . To give you a sample of his philosophy we quote this—EXPl ^ ANATION OP CLAIRVOYANCE . " But opacity is no barrier to the perceptions of internal sight ;—that is , when this internal faculty is fully developed , and its subject in a proper state . Objects to which the mind may be directed , either designedly or spontaneously , will be equally visible through doors and walls , as if placed directly before the face . Nay more , speaking from experience , to the higher stages of clairvoyance there seems , comparatively speaking , no bounds ; for , whether the object sought be in the same house , or town , or country , or across the broad atlantic or pacific oceans , it appears to be found and seen with equal facility , and to be equally near to the internal perception of the truly clairvoyant individual . The human body is seen as clearly , and its living actions described as plainly , as if the external and internal parts were alike as transparent as glass , and this , at times , without any bodily connection , such as by bringing the clairvoyant and the person to be examined together , but when many miles have intervened between them .
<( But here a marked difference between external and internal sight may be pointed out : external sight is essentially of a passive character ; internal sight as essentially active . It is true , a certain degree of attention is necessary in order to our distinctly seeing objects , inasmuch as an object maybe directly before us , and yet not observed . But the image of the object is imprinted on the retina , although , from the concentration of the mind on some other subject , the sensation is not perceived . When , however , the mind is unoccupied , we cannot help seeing such objects as are within therange ' of vision , the impression is made , and the sensation is experienced . Both the light and the impiession come from without , wholly independant of our volition , and the object may be said
t . ) come to the eye . But in internal vision , the sight , as it were , goes to the object . The light , or that which to the clairvoyant is analogous to light , is projected from within ; an active exercise of volition takes place ; as the spark flit's from the excited electric machine , so the perception seems , as it were , to seek the corresponding sensation . This active character of internal vision I have repeatedly noticed , and the elairvoyante in whom I perceived it , hns also said that , to her perception , light issued from the brain ; at other times , that all things seemed light , but that the light did not appear like either day light , or artificial light , but something brighter and more intense . This , of course , when the faculty was at its fullest state of development . "
For the sake of bringing this expl mation within the accepted theories of Mesmerism , and of presenting the reader with a compendious statement of the actual condition of the science , we have drawn up the following : — There is in nature a universally diffused fluid or force , called Odyle . It is a bluish light ; and is intelligent , if not omniscient . ( Vide Leader , No . ( iO . ) When the brain is in ita normal condition , this odyle comes from external objects , and communicates to the brain certain truths relating to those objects ; but if by chance the brain is in un abnormal condition , then the odyle passes from the brain to the objects ( no matter how many thousand
miles removed in point of space , nor how many hundred years in point of time ) . and having once reached the objects , returns again to the brain and communicates tho results of its inquiries . The sailors who accompany Sir John Franklin see him : the odylo passes from him to them ; but " Emma , " at Hoi ton , soon Sir John Franklin in the polar regions : the odyle pannes from her to him . That is all the difference-. Major Buckley ' s friend seen a ring , the odyle passes from it to Iuk brain ; but the mesmerized patient wees tho ring , und then the odyle pauses from her to tho ring , and ' backward thrf ffjg h the eonturicH till it alight upon Mary Queen of Scots , and David Rizzio I Now , when a *¦ party "—to use Dr . Haddock ' m favourite vulgarism .- — ncba forth u philosophy like that in a style liko Dr . Huddpck ' a , who can wonder if other " parties" regmd thia " party" un perhaps on tb « whole an oV » taclo to the progress of
mesmeric science ? Who can wonder if " fac T * » are received with suspicion when they are of th ' kind : — dls Once , a gentleman asked me unexpectedly j n neighbour ' s house , several doors from mine , to m a meriae him ; I tried , but did not succeed . ' r S * turning home , I found Emma in the mesmeric 8 tat " and , upon inquiry , discovered that she had gone inf ' that state while engaged with needle-work , and ? the time I was endeavouring to mesmerise the ' gentl HI £ 111 On another occasion , Dr . Haddock , while visit . ing a patient who was suffering from delirium
tremetis , tried the soothing influence of mesmerism and on his return home found " Emma" had gone into the mesmeric state at the very moment he was operating on his patient . He has no misgivings The possibility of deceit or of coincidence never strikes him . His own power of mesmerism does it all . Distance is nothing to him ; cannot the od y le travel faster than lightning ? Yet Dr . Haddock , so credulous of his own facts is somewhat severe upon poor Cahagnet , whom we reviewed last week : —
" Having repeatedly been asked for my opinion , I now very briefly advert to another work , quite the opposite to that just referred to ; I mean Cahag net ' t Celestial Telegraph ; or , ihe Secrets of the Oilier Life unveiled , # c . If Miss Martineau and her coadjutor are deficient in faith , Oahagnet certainly is not ; but with him faith degenerates into credulity . In the absence of all personal knowledge it would be wrong to assert any want of honesty , or intention to deceive . But I have very great doubt as to the dependence which can be placed upon Cahagnet and his coadjutors as careful and trustworthy observers . The
tendency to the marvellous is so evident , that even their soberest relations must be received with great caution . When , in the second volume , we find him speaking of material substances , such as lost jewels , boxes , &c , being brought from a distance and transported with the velocity of lightning through space , at the potent command , or spell , of certain mesmeric or magic individnals ; and again of showers of stones descending through impossible places , or in the way of miracle , we may reasonably question the judgment , if not the honesty , of a writer , who could gravely narrate such , things . "
Really we do not see where Dr . Haddock draws the line . " That material substances should be brought from a distance with the velocity of lightning , by mere volition of a mesmerized patient , is certainly not on the face of ita very credible story ; but we do not see why the judgment and honesty of the narrator should be doubted by a man who narrates such stories as Dr . Haddock narrates in this volume . If he imagines that his stories are much more credible , or related in a more authoritative style , we feel it a kindness to undeceive him . The best are too long for extract , but this will 6 erve our turn : —
" The following experiment was interesting , as affording some clue to the mode by which distant objects were perceived , a ? id clearly showing the possibility of a clairvoyant ' s being able to perceive the active sentiments or ideas of the mind of a distant individual . I had directed Emma's attention to a female relative in London ; she speedily found her , and began to describe her residence , &e . ; butsuddenly her attention ceaned to be directed to my relative , and she became engrossed with- the description of a magnificent residence , with its elegant und costly furniture ; a lady lying in a superb bed ; a beautifully
dresHed baby ; well dressed ladies in und about the room , and another room in which were older children , also beautifully dressed , and attended by ladies . From many replies to my inquiries , I considered that the only pluco to which her impassioned descriptions could refer was Buckingham Palace , for the aecouchinent of tho Queen hud then recently occurred I therefore mud , with the view of ascertaining tho correctness of my conjecture , ' Do you nee any soldiers there ? ' ' Yes , ' > -he replied , ' there arc . soldiers ut the door . ' I then wnv that my conjecture might he correct ; but why she nhould have spontaneously gonr there , without any request or desire on mypi " ! or the most remote idea of making royalty the Miojuct of l
experiment , was a myHteiy . J 5 ut after I » * informed my relative of the occunenee , I obtained the clue , to Urn seemingly mysterious transition from one subject to another ; for J was informed that she had been thinking of the interesting circumstances tit which t / m Queen was then placed , and aluo of the t : iui <>' faculty of my Bolton cluii voynnte , and felt desirotm to know whether Emma had the power to visit and describe the interior of the palace at thut time . The cause , therefore , of 1 ' jinnm ' n unexpected visit to royalty wrh this : my relative had wished her to go there ; when brought into muHinerio connection with her , the active sentiment of her mind wan coinmumcntud to EminiiH mind , and by thiu moans her attention w »» uneonociouuly directed ( , o tho royal residence . But t" « wuh further confirmation that thia was tho true c » u « c ,
Untitled Article
636 file H $ fl ) in [ Saturday ,
-
-
Citation
-
Leader (1850-1860), July 5, 1851, page 636, in the Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition (2008; 2018) ncse-os.kdl.kcl.ac.uk/periodicals/l/issues/vm2-ncseproduct1890/page/16/
-