Current:

Leader (1850-1860), 28th August 1858, Edition 1 of 2, Page 872, ¦ ——? :— ' ' . Critics are not the legis...

Page 872
Page 16
16 of 32

On this page

  • Departments (1)
    • . 4| tff rntiirP — ** v**•*«•??*?¦- ?
  • Text (5)
  • Transcript

    • Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.

      Additionally, when viewing full transcripts, extracted text may not be in the same order as the original document.

      872 The Leader. [No. 440, August 28,1858...

      872 THE LEADER . [ No . 440 , August 28 , 1858 .

      . 4| Tff Rntiirp — ** V**•*«•??*?¦- ?

      literntnrL

      ¦ ——? :— ' ' . Critics Are Not The Legis...

      ¦ ——? : — ' ' . Critics are not the legislators , "but the judges and police of literature . They do not make laws—thej- interpret and try to enforce them . —Edinburgh Revieto .

      ¦ _? Private Journal Oj Tpie Marquis Of ...

      ¦ _? PRIVATE JOURNAL OJ TPIE MARQUIS OF HASTINGS . The Private Journal of the Marquess of Hastings , K . Gf . Governor-General and Commander-in-Chief in India Edited by his Daughter , the Marchioness of Bute . In Two Volumes . Saunders and Otley . "Francis , Earl of Moira , afterwards created Marquis of Hastings , is a great name even among the great names of the liistory of British India .

      Appointed chiefly for Iris soldierly qualities by the very party whom he had be

      —unusually long as it was—which were not subjected to fierce criticism , it had at all events one great merit . It was no hand-to-mouth system ; no staving off of the deluge , intlie hope that things would just outlast the tenure of his power . It was based oh principles . It had an idea . It recognised other forces than fcayonets and artillery . It attributed a just value to opinion , ev < sn in the minds of half barbarous rapes . Troubles unparalleled , even in Indian hj » tory , fierce struggles for our very footing upon ^ Indian ground , insuiTection , anarchy , and financial embarrassment , delayed for a -while the

      practical exposition of liis views ; but they were never lost sight of . He had determined to raise the character of the English masters of that great continent ; to convince his subjects of our honesty and justice , and of the beneficial effects that might be expected from , our rule . Such a policj , Ave regret to say , little suited the views or tastes of many Englishmen who had gone out to the East witk the remembrance of what things had been . The ^ days of rapine and fraud , and shameless corruption , were still too near for all to believe that they -were at an end , or to be satisfied with the

      better reign . "Never yet since the first days of our rule had the sword rested in the scabbard : but Government cannot always be at war . It was time to look to the consolidation of our power ; it was time to settle its foundations deep in the interests of the races under our government or protection , or prepare to he swept away by the first great storm that should unexpectedly arise . Lord Moira felt this . He has been charged with -vanity , with ambition , with tlie desire to leave behind him the memory of a brilliant career ; but such charges suggest tlieir own refutation . Pew men escape

      similar accusations who arc possessed of honest purpose and menial energy—of the courage to think and to act for themselves . His powers for evil as well as good were such as few men could be prudently entrusted with . By his own solicitation he was constituted both Governor-General and Cornmander-in-Chief , with the salary of one office only , and over the whole of Britisli India lie was as , even in these days of steam and telegraphs and overland routes no Britisli Governor-General of India will probably be , practically omnipotent . But no enemy ever has accused him of having abused these powers . Indian morality had indeed not yet attained that nigh standard by which an . attempt to put an end

      to war by bribing the Nepnulese commander would appear , even to a mind so frank and honest as that of Lord Moira , anything but a fair stratagem : but "SV ^ Iwnwett uncorruptible . In the unfortunate affair with Palmer and fco , and the N izam , in which nis baste to defend a relative ut \ d other unfortunate circumstances tnightrhave appeared to involve him . the Governor-General ' s known character was his best shield . INo historian has hesitated to acquit him on that point . What he gained by his longlnd arduous government was patent to the world . The grants ot the East India Company to himself and His family were the ungrudged reward of his aervides . The rest was beyond the power of Leadenhall-street to . bestow—the title to a good name .

      These two volumes introduce us to little of the political or even of the military history of the Government of Lord Hastings . They break off in 1818 , and comprise but one half of the period of

      his Governor-Generalship ; but , even as far as they extend , they note little but his travels in the country and his observations upon the people , their manners , customs , and religion , although his interviews with native princes and others are recorded in sufficient detail to show the spirit of his rule . The book is iijdeed clearly what it professes to be—a journal undertaken for the sake only of the children who accompanied him , in the hope that it would be " both gratifying and useful to them in a future circumstances

      day to have their recollection of revived , and to have many matters explained which they would be likely to have comprehended but imperfectly . " Indeed , the long withholding of the manuscript by the survivors of these children is a sufficient evidence that it had been always considered of a private character , which fact would probably have still prevented its publication but for the public interest in India now awakened , and the increased desire for such information as can be drawn from the writings of our great Indian

      statesmen . The quick eye of the new Governor-General for a political error cannot be better exemplified than by the following passage . The evil which it . points oat unfortunately survived the writer ' s administration : — February , 1816 . —Our ordinances in tins country have been generally instigated by some casual occurrence . In other countries , laws are only recognitions and enforcements of settled opinions of the community , and as these opinions are the result of long observation and practical experience , there is little danger that an edict founded on them should be inconvenient to society . From the

      want of a comprehensive view in our system , many of our regulations , while they correct one evil , institute many sources of oppression . When we invested the zemindars with the proprietary which they were before the superintendents , it became necessary to secure to Government the regular payment of the rent reserved for the State ; and for this purpose the law was established that , in the event of arrears to Government , the whole estate should be put up foT sale , the residue of its produce ( after Government should have paid itself ) being restored to the zemindar . This was evidently framed upon a contemplation of the confined zemindarrics near Calcutta . A detect ion of the mischief of this practice was one of the advantages arising from my tour up the countrv . Manv of the zemindarries are

      of such extent that there can scarcely be any competition of bidders for them . ;¦ but what is still more material , the native officers round the collector form such combinations that purchasers are intimidated frorri coming forward ; bankers are threatened if they attempt to nid the defaulter ; and the estate is sold to one of the gang ; for perhaps a tenth of its value . If any man be suspected of endeavouring to get at the collector in order to open his eyes , a forged accusation of some criminal procedure is made to the magistrate against him , and is supported by perjured testimony . The individual is instantly imprisoned , and lies there till his turn For examination comes on the file , which may rot be for many weeks . In the meantime the sale is despatched . I communicated my remarks on this evil , but . the correctives vere insufficient . Attention is called anew to the

      case of a singular circumstance . Through a strange want of consideration in the collector , a frontier zemindarry , of at least twenty miles square , was advertised for sale for an iirrcar of 700 rupees . The magistrate luckSljheard of ir , and stopped the procedure by paying the etim for tlic zemindar . Wo shall , now put effectual guards against the abuse . This passage , it will be observed , does not touch the views of the writer on the merits of the permanent sctttlcmcnt ; but we find these recorded

      elsewhere . In no point does the force of prejudice and of prevalent ideas appear more strongly than in the remarks of the journalist oiv this important subject . It was flic fashion then , as it still is , with Indian officials , to decry the work of Lord Coniwullis ; to treat remediable or incidental defects in that system as radical or essential to it ; and to attribute evils beyond the power of any kind of settlement to remove as springing directly from it . This cannot be more forcibly shown than by the following passage on the permanent settlement : —

      Much oversight wjiB committed in thnt arrangement , which ( us it wae managed ) was more specious than really beneficial . It wna assumed that the zemindar *) were tlio real landowners , and that , commanding as such tlio attachment of the peasantry , they would ensure tlio adherence of tho latter to our Government if their own interest in the land were secured from prccatlousness or extortion . On this principle , the proprietary right of tho zemindar to the tract under hi » management v / a » declared , subject to his paying In perpetuity to Government a quit-rent , settled generally by the rate at which he wat actually assessed . " Where tho payment yrna heavy , it was aupposed the zemindar would Indemtiiry hlmaelf by an improved cultivation or by bringing into

      tillage the waste lands thrown in without charge m 7 n the allotment assigned him . It was forgotten tfiuhe zemindar was not the cultivator , and no protection w »! given to the ryot , the real tiller ( perhaps the rea ? ^ prietor ) of the soil , against the oppressive exactions of tT zemindar , whose actual dependent he was madebv tlii settlement . In fact , the zemindar was originally nothing more than the contractor -with the native government for the rent of a certain district . He resembled tlII middle-man in Ireland . The indolence of admiiiistra tions would render this contract generally hereditary In many cases the contract was in some old family dos " T ^ J ™ ™?^«^™^ ou £ l rt

      ^^^ thence exercising considerable influence over them ' w in many other instances tlie rum of respected stocks had caused their place to be occupied by upstart adventurer * hateful to the people , and hating them in return . In either supposition , where the rent demanded of the seniindar was high , he looked to discharge it as well as to provide fur his own maintenance by squeezing the ryot . He never felt an urgency for advancing money to bring the waste land into cultivation ; the ryot could not engnge in such- a speculation when he -was " at the mercy of the zemindar 5 therefore little of the ground ¦ which was waste has been brought into tillage-where the permanent settlement exists .

      The merest novice in political philosophy would we should think , have no difficulty in answering these objections . Whether good or bad , it docs not appear to liaye occurred to Lord Hastings that the very same criticism must be applicable to England , and to almost all but Oriental countries . Ifc was in the belief , that-the European system of landlord and tenant worked well , and that the Eastern system of a Government hmdlord , confounding tax mid rent , and giving the cultivator no proprietary right , or any power to acquire a proprietary right , in the soil , was most pernicious in its effects , that Lord Cornwallis devised liis famous settlement .

      All European ' writers / agree that ryot rents . ' are more hopelessly destructive of the property and progress of the people than any other form of the relation of landlord and tenant . The notion tluittlie cultivator requires -protection , from the zemindar , any . more than the English farmer from his landlord , rests on no good foundation . The zemindar can no more ' squeeze the ryot than any oilier party in a free contract , lie must be subject to tlic competition of other landlords equally anxious to procure good tenants . He . must have the same motive for

      advancing money— -if . lie has any to advance—to his tenants whicli other capitalists have ; and if Iris power to sublet and give his tenant sure possession were perfect—which , it unfortunately is not—he would have precisely the same interest in granting leases which an English landlord has , for without some such protection , the tenant will not cultivate well , and if he cannot cult ivutc well , he cannot pay rent . Tlie simple principles of free trade , with as

      little as possible of State interference , are as applicable to India as to England . It is , we are convinced , not in tlic-nbandoiimci . it , but in thp extension and perfecting of the system of private landlords , protected by a fixed tax from the arbitrary exactions , or even tlic well-intentioned intermeddling of the state , that we must look for improvement in Indian . agriculture and commerce , and the general condition of the people . , ot

      The Journal" contains but few indications the perilous character of the times—our disasters in the war with Ncpaul , our dangers from the rising hopes of the native princes , from the unchecked marauding of Pinclarrecs and Pathans , and irom ft discontent , only too well founded , at our rule Such ns it does contain arc fragmentary , mid require an elucidation which the fair and noble editor has not given us . AVc rogrct ibis , because it will prevent the " Journal" being us useful as it mig ht , be . The troubles of that period , instructive as they arc at the present time , arc too remotu to bo mquireii [ nin Uv ovprv roiuliT A vrw slifrht skdcli WOllltt

      have given him a key , and . remedial this delect ; but . Ilio Marchioness of Bute has done nothing out send the manuscript to the printer , with a prelaw whose bad taste and absurd magniloquence mo much to be regretted .

      The Indian Rebellion. Eight Mouths' Camj...

      THE INDIAN REBELLION . Eight Mouths' Camjmign rif / uimt the Btvynl Sepoy Army . Hy Col . George Jlonrehicr , C . B ., ltengnl Horso Artillery , late Commanding No . 17 Light Field Unitary . Smith , Kldcr , < m < l Co . Personal Adventures dur ' mq the Indian Jtebellwn . » y William Edwards , Esq ., Judge or Uennrcs , nnd »» Magistrate and Collector of Budnan , in Hohilcuna . Smith , Elder , on « l Co . While from day to any the publishers announce new works bearing upon Indian affairs , and particM-

  • Citation
    • Leader (1850-1860), Aug. 28, 1858, page 872, in the Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition (2008; 2018) ncse-os.kdl.kcl.ac.uk/periodicals/l/issues/ldr_28081858/page/16/