On this page

• Text (3)

  Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.

  • 

    84t THE LEAPEB, [No. 357,Sattopa^

  • 

    ALICIA. RA.CE. The case of the Queeh ver...

  • 

    WORK WANTED. "When thirty-five thousand ...

• Transcript

  • Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software. The text has not been manually corrected and should not be relied on to be an accurate representation of the item.

    Additionally, when viewing full transcripts, extracted text may not be in the same order as the original document.

    Success Of The Income-Tax Agitation. Tii...

    oblige his personal acquaintances , and the subject ; was heard of no more . Is thai the courage or the principle of a Liberal representative ? The man useful in the House of Commons would be one who , cautious as well as bold , would never allow a trick of finance or policy to pass without reprobating and exposing it . The Uxeter Hall meeting was important , although , in a platform sense , a failure . It was more than a metropolitan demonstration .

    He roin , northern and southern , maritime and midland towns and counties came the deputies of local committees , pledging themselves to act with the utmost energy in aid of the Central Association . Only one sentiment was expressed , and that an unmistakable resolve not to submit to the imposition of the war ninepence for another year , and not to tolerate the tax to any amount unless readjusted upon principles of equity . The nation has begun to study finance , as well

    as foreign affairs . It perceives , though as yet dimly , what profits accrued to the agricultural and ecclesiastical orders during the late war ; how the corn averages are balanced ; how property is fenced round with exemptions ; how the industry of hand and brain , the field that never lies fallow , is worked for the benefit of the Exchequer ; hovr , indeed , laws are still class-made , with class objects , excessive burdens balanced against unfair immunities .

    The Income-tax question is only part of a larger question , -which , again , affects the general interest of the nation in a reform of the House of Commons . Could Sir Cobne-WAiii Lewis qujbble over a date , and dishonestly interline an Act of Parliament in the presence of a real Liberal party ? Legislation of that character would be impossible ,

    were it not for the carelessness , incompetency , and insincerity of some who occupy the independent benches . " We may abolish the war ninepence ; we may repeal the tax altogether ; but , if we would be safely and wisely governed , we must do that which will not be done by the Cheapside Association , active as it is , and excellent as are its objects .

    84t The Leapeb, [No. 357,Sattopa^

    84 t THE LEAPEB , [ No . 357 , Sattopa ^

    Alicia. Ra.Ce. The Case Of The Queeh Ver...

    ALICIA . RA . CE . The case of the Queeh versus Mama CiiAuBKE has been confused in the minds of many honest people , partly by the prejudice naturally excited in a conflict between Protestantism and Catholicism , and partly by permitting the main principle at stake to be mixed up with collateral and subordinate considerations . The story is simple . Alicia

    Uaoe is the daughter of a sergeant ; who perished in the "battle of Petropaulowski . Before his death , he made a will , bequeathing the care of his children to his wife ; he was a Protestant , the wife a Roman Catholic . She procured admission for the boy to the Sailors' Orphan Boys' School , in Dorsetshire , and for the girl , Alicia , to the Sailors ' Orphan Girla' School , at Hampsfcead . Becently , however , Mrs . Back has altered her

    views respecting the children , and she required them to be delivered up to her . The boy was surrendered , but the authorities of the girla' school at HampBtead refused . The child , who is ten years of age , wrote a letter , begging that she might be permitted to remain in the school , and saying that she declined to be surrendered to her mother ; that she d

    preferre" to worship the Lord Jesus" in the Protestant manner , and did not wish to worship the Virgin Mary . This letter , it was said , had been written by her without any compulsion , and was , in fact , her own free choice . TJhe authorities of the school were supported hy the Commissioners of the Patriotic tfund . Mrs . Haoh moved fora writ

    of habeas corpus to bring Maria Clarke before th . e Court of Queen ' s Bench , that she might be delivered to her mother , and the writ was opposed by Mr . O'Majllet . The main argument in bar of " the delivery was thisz—The father had always brought up his children as Protestants , and attended a Protestant school ; he had always attended the Church of England ; eight months after their father ' s death the children attended Protestant school and worship , the mother

    going with them . This was . the way she had interpreted her husband ' s wish that she would " do justice '' to his children . They had been placed in Protestant schools with her approbation . She avowed that it went to her heart to take the children away ; but some gentlemen " would not do anything for the boy , unless she took away the girl also . " Her object was to place the child under the care of priests , which would frustrate the

    father ' s dying wishes ; and therefore , urged Mr . O'Mallet , the child should be educated in the r-eligion of the father , and not surrendered to the mother . If it were the primary object of law regulating the relations of parent and child that a child should be brought up in the Protestant faith , there is no doubt that Mr . O'MALiiEY was right , and that Aeicia Hace ought not to be surrendered to her mother .

    But in the eye of the law the Protestant and the Eoman Catliolic faith are equal . Parents have a right to choose the one or the other . However wrong the one faith may be , and the other right , that freedom is conceded . We may try this principle by reversing the circumstances of the case . Let us suppose that Alicia Race had been the daughter of a Roman Catholic father , and that her mother , having ; placed her at a Roman Catholic school ,

    had afterwards changed counsel and proposed to take her avray : would there have been the same difficulty in conceding the paramount force of parental authority ? We doubt it . At all events , the principle involved in the case would hare presented itself much more clearly to those who have discussed it with an expression of " regret" that the Court of Queen ' a Bench should have been compelled to carry out the law !

    It is said that the same rule should be followed as in the Greenwich and Chelsea Schools—namely , that the child should be educated in the religion of the father ; but that is not the question . It is not the case of an orphan "who is found in the school , and respecting whom an impartial State desires to determine that choice of faith which a child cannot make for itself : the decision is then left for presumption , a presumptive conjecture of the parent ' s probable choice , and the rule laid down is the nearest approach to justice whicli can be made .

    The mother herself , it is remarked , had originally determined the choice of a faith in accordance -with the presumed wish of the father , whereas she h as now changed her mind ; but parents have a right to change their minds . It would introduce a totally new principle into English law if the State , or some other persons , had a right to interfere with the charge of children , on the display of vacillation , inconsistency , or even gross caprice in parents . Some parents would soon have police or ' commissioners * entering their street doors !

    Another argument is , that Mrs . Hack has been tampered with , —that the application for tho surrender of her children is not spontaneous on her part , tho motives are not herd , but that she is moved by some other poraons . This again is introducing a still more novel and dangerous principle into the regulation of society . It would call upon us to . admit parental authority , if the motives

    were rational , but to deny it , if we disputed the ^ motives , and to hunt up the motives behind the express declaration of the parent . "What endless litigation , interference , and perversion of all domestic authority would result from the establishment-of any such principle . One of the strongest averments is , that the girl herself " prefers" the Protestant faith ; but to admit this plea would be subversive of all authority in the family . The opinion of a

    child , ten years old , is received in contradiction to the opinion of the mother . No doubt the tutors of the child , the managers of the school , and the Royal Patriotic Fund sustain the infant ; but what then ? Is it to be allowed in England , that a child can stand forward and say that ifc disapproves of its parents' theological tenets ? Is the opinion of the parents to give way before the opinion of the child , plus the opinion of some schoolmaster and some charitable commissioners ?

    If the rule holds good because Alicia Race happens to be in a school where her theology and the theology of the teachers and commissioners agree , it would equally hold good for- a child , actually in parental custody , who might claini to depart , and seek her home and guardians as seemed best to her own judgment . And it was Englishmen , admirers of our constitution , of our civil and religious liberty , that , in horror at the idea of seeing Aiicia Hace become a Catholie , would have made a wholesale sacrifice of

    maternal authority to rescue that one child ! Let us ask what would have become then of all the other little children of England now happily in charge of their mothers ?

    Work Wanted. "When Thirty-Five Thousand ...

    WORK WANTED . "When thirty-five thousand men are in a state of destitution , in London alone , they are told to emigrate , blamed for not having saved money , ridiculed for assembling to deliberate upon their unhappy condition . But the point is , they are in want of the means of life—they and their families—and know not how to procure them . We repeat our advice that they should work the Poor-law to its full extent .

    They are essentially' ' casual poor . ' The law of settlement ^ therefore , does not apply to them . Irrespectively of settlement , tbey have a right to relief in whatever parishes located . Should it be opposed to their claims that they must dispose of their tools and furniture before subsisting on Poor-law allowances , they have only to increase their pressure , and technicalities will give way . They may , without impropriety , demand to be maintained , unless society can provide

    them with employment . Let us not be told that the working classes are idle or improvident . They labour as long as there is labour to be had . Thej * save while there arc wages to receive . There are thirty-five thousand benefit organizations in this country , supported by working men . The unemployed artisans in the metropolis have saved , and have spent their savings . Is it thought by the comfortable cynics who talk of Australia and Socialism , that these are the first days of destitution ia London this winter ? Far from it . Work

    was wanting for thousands many weeks ago ; they have been suffering in silenco until now ; nnd tho well-fed Malthusiana inform them , in a merry way , that it ia by no means an unusual thing ibr the poor to luavo neither bread nor lire during the coldest and moat hungry months of tho year . They know it , themselves , well enough ; but they ought to remember the Midland precedent , tho thousands flocking to the Unions , and being supplied , not only with food , but employment also . Poverty ia not always identical ¦ w ith pauperism . Tho independent labouror , cut

• Citation
  • Leader (1850-1860), Jan. 24, 1857, page 12, in the Nineteenth-Century Serials Edition (2008; 2018) ncse-os.kdl.kcl.ac.uk/periodicals/l/issues/cld_24011857/page/12/